Return to Main Newsletter Page
POST-POLIO NETWORK (NSW) INC.
N E W S L E T T E R #39
Editor: Gillian Thomas
PO Box 888 Kensington
Email: secretary@post-polionetwork.org.au NSW
AUSTRALIA 1465
Website: www.post-polionetwork.org.au Phone
No: (02) 9663 2402
President's Corner Gillian Thomas
At the Network's tenth Annual General Meeting held on 31 October 1998, the following members were elected to the Management Committee. The incoming Committee is already working hard to further the Network's goals.
Gillian Thomas President / Newsletter Editor
Merle Thompson Vice-President
Alice Smart Secretary
Peter Preneas Treasurer
Carmelita Bongco Minutes Secretary
Anne Buchanan Information Bulletin Co-Compiler
Jan Burgess Publicity Officer
Bernie O'Grady Support Group Co-ordinator
Anne O'Halloran Funding Co-ordinator
Allan Quirk Committee Member
Mary Westbrook Seminar Program Co-ordinator
Ruth Wyatt Office Co-ordinator
On 27 October I and three other Network members (Hazel Atkinson, Bernie O'Grady, and Allan Quirk) presented a session on Post-Polio Syndrome in an Orthopaedic Nursing Course conducted by the Northern Sydney Area Health Service. This gave us an opportunity to relate our polio stories and speak directly to nurses about how individual our polio-related disabilities are, and the implications this has for nursing care. Our session was very well received and plans are in progress for Network members to participate in similar courses run by other Area Health Services.
Post-Polio Awareness Week was held from 1-7 November. Thanks to your magnificent support in promoting the Week, we received many new enquiries, and several members told their stories via their local radio stations and newspapers. We also had national coverage on ABC News Radio.
Office Co-ordinator Ruth Wyatt recently convened a meeting of members who have volunteered to staff the Network's office within the Royal South Sydney Community Health Complex, Joynton Avenue, Zetland. We are planning to officially open the office from 2 February 1999, with two volunteers rostered to staff it from 10:00 am to 2:00 pm, Monday to Friday. To achieve this we still need more volunteers, so if you can help, please contact Ruth on (02) 9416 4287 or Alice on (02) 9747 4694.
The following are included with this Newsletter:
- A 1999 Calendar which features some of the Network members who attended
this year's Conference in Canberra. If you don't need the Calendar, please
don't throw it out - pass it on to a friend or put it up somewhere in your
local community. We must all try to bring the Network to the attention of
polio survivors who may not be aware of our existence.
- Order Form for the 1996 Conference Proceedings and audio
tapes, the 1998 Conference audio tapes, our membership survey report Polio
- A Challenge for Life - The Impact of Late Effects, and our popular Network
T-Shirt.
Finally, if your address label still reads "Renewal
Due on 1 July 1998" we have not yet received your membership renewal.
In this case, you will find a Membership Renewal Form enclosed. Please help
us to help you by sending in your membership subscription as soon as possible.
Unless otherwise stated, the articles in this
Newsletter may be reprinted provided that they are reproduced in full (including
any references) and the author, the source and the Post-Polio Network (NSW)
Inc are acknowledged in full. Articles may not be edited or summarised without
the prior written approval of the Network. The views expressed in this publication
are not necessarily those of the Network, and any products and services described
are not necessarily endorsed or recommended by the Network.
Orthotics
Outlook
Michael Gurry B.Pros.&Orth., M.A.O.P.A.
Orthotic Consultants Asia Pacific Pty Ltd
In the first edition of Orthotics Outlook an
introduction as to who an Orthotist is and where you can find additional information
regarding your orthoses was covered. In this edition the way in which orthoses
are described will be covered as well as the basics of foot and ankle foot
orthotics.
Nomenclature
The way in which an orthosis is described is by which
parts of the body the orthosis covers and which joints it encompasses. For
example an AFO is an Ankle Foot Orthosis, a KAFO is a Knee Ankle Foot Orthosis,
an LSO is a Lumbar Sacral Orthosis and a TLSO is a Thoracic Lumbar Sacral
Orthosis. As well as these broad descriptions of the orthosis, a more specific
breakdown of the type of orthosis may be described by the function and type
of materials and components used. For example an AFO may be plastic or metal.
It may have an ankle joint or be fixed. It may assist function or resist movement.
So in a description of an AFO we may say: "a thermoplastic AFO with Tamarak
ankle joints and posterior adjustable plantarflexion stop".
Foot Orthoses
Foot orthoses is an area where orthotists and podiatrists
overlap in terms of treatment. You are probably aware that for many years
there has been a fundamental difference in the way in which the two professions
approach them. Orthotists have for many years fabricated what are classed
as semi-rigid style foot orthoses while podiatrists have fabricated more rigid
styles. Neither are right or wrong. In fact we are finding that there is much
common ground in the middle using some of the podiatry alignment techniques
with orthotists' material selection and fabrication know-how. It is a fast
evolving area with many podiatrists using more flexible materials. Foot orthotics
can play a major part in changing the alignment of higher body components.
They can therefore have a beneficial role to play. However great care is required
at the time of assessment to ensure that the body hasn't rigidly adapted to
a set alignment, in which case the orthosis may aggravate, or even cause,
other pains or complications. Not everyone needs foot orthoses.
Ankle Foot Orthoses (AFO)
As mentioned above AFOs may take many forms. The thing
to keep in mind is the outcome you are trying to achieve. The functional requirements
will determine the style of components used. The physical condition of the
limb will determine the materials to be used. The size and weight and activity
level of the individual may influence the strength required. Plastic AFOs
can be light weight, moved easily between shoes, are cosmetically sensitive
and if fitted well can provide excellent control. The contra-indications for
plastic are those people with decreased or no sensation, or thin papery skin,
diabetics and those whose limbs swell a lot during the day. Metal AFOs are
indicated where plastic is a contra-indication. The metal can be heavier,
less cosmetic and requires all shoes to be modified, but does have minimal
contact with poor skin and does allow for fluctuating swelling in the limb.
Your orthotist in the course of his/her assessment can discuss the needs and
outcomes you wish to achieve and formulate a realistic and achievable treatment
plan.
If you have any questions ring your local orthotist
or contact me on Phone: (02) 9553 6669,
Email orthcon@hutch.com.au. I look forward to your correspondence and
wish you all a safe and happy Christmas and New Year.
Recognising the Effects
of Non-Polio Health Problems on Post-Polio Symptoms
Frederick Maynard MD
Frederick Maynard, MD, is Medical Director and Clinical Director, Department
of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, MetroHealth Center for Rehabilitation,
and Faculty, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio.
This article is reprinted from "Polio Network News",
Vol. 12, No. 2, with permission of Gazette International Networking Institute,
4207 Lindell Blvd., #110, Saint Louis, Missouri 63108-2915, USA. Permission
to reproduce the article must be sought from Gazette International Networking
Institute.
I want to talk about problems unrelated to a polio history and polio residuals:
the co-morbidities, or other medical conditions that have nothing to do with
one's polio condition but that may occur during the course of living and growing
older.
Polio survivors can and do develop common medical problems
like diabetes and heart disease, for example, that accelerate the decline
in their nerve conduction velocity and further disrupt the functioning of
their polio damaged motor units. Such an "extra" medical problem
has a bigger effect on the ability of survivors to walk, to care for themselves,
or to work than it would in people who have the same degree of diabetes and
nerve conduction problems but did not have any original weakness in their
muscles from polio nerve damage.
Secondary disability is another name for new medical
conditions that can occur during the life of a person with a disability (see
Polio Network News, Vol. 11, No. 1, p. 3). If we consider previous
paralytic polio as the primary disabling condition, and then add in the influences
of individual lifestyle and behaviour, of the environment, of intrinsic genetic
biology, we have the mediating factors that determine whether new pathologies
(like coronary artery disease or diabetes or intestinal problems) will progress
to result in new impairments (greater weakness) or greater functional limitations
(more trouble walking). If you have an initial primary disability (polio),
and then you get something else (diabetes), you may develop secondary disabilities
of greater impact more quickly than someone without polio. Of course, the
degree of impairment and disability can influence one's quality of life.
There are a lot of different trajectories or downhill
courses for functional capacity over the lifespan of a person with polio.
I believe that the biggest determinant of the polio survivor's slope is whether
they do or do not develop other medical conditions: how many and how severe
they are. These conditions lead to the disabling weakness and fatigue associated
with the name "post-polio syndrome". Loss of function can occur
quickly if you have an injury or a severe, sudden onset of a medical condition.
For example, after a heart attack, you have such reduced heart function that
you cannot exercise or remain active for very long. This will quickly result
in greater muscle weakness and more trouble walking. When such conditions
come on, they can rapidly sap your strength and make life much more difficult.
When Lauro Halstead, MD, National Rehabilitation Hospital,
Washington DC, interviewed some 10 injured post-polio survivors, regarding
how long it took them to recover from an injury as compared to people without
polio, he estimated that it took approximately 12 times as long. A rule of
thumb is that for every one day "normal" people spend in bedrest
and undergo deconditioning of muscle, heart, and lung function, they must
spend at least two or three days working to regain the lost functional capacity
of these organs. Polio survivors may have to spend 10, 12, or 15 days fighting
to recover from every one day of forced inactivity.
When my research colleagues and I at the University
of Michigan studied co-morbidities, or "other medical conditions",
in 120 polio survivors, we found that 35% of them - an amazingly high percentage
- had other medical conditions. Furthermore, there was a high correlation
between survivors with other conditions and those reporting reduced ability
to remain active and do their usual activities, that is, those who demonstrated
functional decline. A common secondary condition associated with functional
decline was obesity, and we used 30% over optimal body weight as our definition
of obesity, not just a few extra pounds.
Elevated cholesterol ratio was another secondary condition
associated with functional decline. I am not sure exactly what this finding
means other than that polio survivors are probably more at risk for hardening
of the arteries and coronary artery disease, conditions associated with elevated
cholesterol levels, because they are less active.
Our study also indicated that polio survivors are at
a very high risk for neuromusculoskeletal impairments: more than half had
shoulder pain, 58% had abnormalities in conduction velocity of the median
nerve at the wrist, and at least 30% had carpal tunnel syndrome. Arthritic
changes in the bones of the hand were higher, of course, among people using
crutches, or using their hands to move themselves about in a wheelchair.
Another important co-morbidity is depression. Contrary
to some previous studies, we did not find an overall increased incidence of
depression: only about 18% of the entire sample were depressed, a percentage
actually lower than it is for non-disabled groups of people. Living alone
and having new health problems were among the strongest correlations with
depression. Post-polio people who did not seek out information or professional
help, possible indicators of poor coping skills, also were more likely to
be depressed.
Overall, I am urging people to not look at post-polio
syndrome as a new disease entity in and of itself. Rather, I am suggesting
that they consider it from a life-course perspective as an "at risk"
condition that results from the original polio and its resultant disability,
and that is triggered by the onset of other medical co-morbidities, whether
obesity, depression, heart disease, diabetes, stress, or something else. How
polio survivors respond, both psychologically and behaviourally, as well as
medically, to the onset of this other condition will determine their course
of possible functional decline during the rest of their lives.
Consider a person who has been walking with crutches
for years and begins to have shoulder pain. There are two ways that one could
view this condition. The first is: as the crutch walker gets older and the
collagen tissue that supports the structures of the shoulder joint become
stiffer and less elastic, the shoulder begins to wear out. This view considers
shoulder pain as an age-related, reduced load-bearing ability of the shoulders
that causes them to hurt more than they once did. The second viewpoint is:
as the shoulders grow less resilient, they are used less and their muscles
become weaker. There may be some shoulder muscle atrophy along with the changes
in shoulder joint tissues. At this point, the polio survivor may say, "Oh,
my goodness, I am developing post-polio syndrome; my muscles are getting weaker,
and, therefore, my shoulders are now hurting because my muscles aren't strong
enough to support them any longer. Post-polio syndrome has caused my new pain
and inflammation in the shoulder tissues."
These two viewpoints differ in their attribution of causation for shoulder
pain. "Attribution theory" suggests that our emotional responses
to negative events in our lives is largely determined by our explanation for
why the negative event occurred. Did I develop cancer because God is punishing
me? ... because I ate the wrong foods? ... because they polluted my water?
or ... because cancer sometimes develops by chance? Similarly, how survivors
explain their individual situations can be very important to what they do
about their new symptoms.
Figure 1
Contrasting Paradigms for Evaluating Post-Polio Syndrome
| |
Traditional Medical |
Life-Course |
| Viewed as |
Disease / Illness |
At-Risk Life Event |
| Goal |
Cure |
Prevention |
| Orientation |
Treatment |
Management |
| Etiology |
Unknown |
Known |
| Promotes |
Fear |
Self-Awareness |
| |
Anger |
Emotional Growth |
| |
Hopelessness |
Information Seeking |
| |
Dependency |
Life-Style Change |
| |
Multiple Medical Evaluations |
Health Promotion |
When I put together Figure 1, Contrasting Paradigms for
Evaluating Post-Polio Syndrome, for the National Institutes of Health
scientists, I wanted to offer that there are advantages in looking at post-polio
syndrome as a condition that occurs in the life course of people who have
had previous paralytic polio (the holistic model) rather than as a condition
that views post-polio syndrome as a new disease and illness (the traditional
model).
The medical model expects a cure and prescribes treatment,
as opposed to the life-course model, which focuses on prevention and management
of problems as they occur. On the one hand, we have an unknown cause for a
new disease of post-polio syndrome; on the other hand, we have age-related
factors and other medical conditions occurring in people with prior polio.
I think that the traditional medical model of post-polio syndrome promotes
fear, anger, dependency, hopelessness, and feelings that lead to multiple
expensive medical evaluations, whereas the broader perspective of "post-polio
syndrome" as a life-course event helps promote self-awareness and emotional
growth.
Vale - Elizabeth Hastings
We were deeply saddened to learn of the death of Elizabeth
Hastings in Melbourne on 13 October 1998 of breast cancer, aged 49. Elizabeth
contracted polio as a two-month old baby and used a wheelchair throughout
her life. Appointed in 1993 as Australia's first Disability Discrimination
Commissioner, Elizabeth's contribution to the promotion of the rights of people
with disabilities was significant; she was never afraid to push forward into
controversial areas and did so with profound awareness and critical insight.
In August 1994, Elizabeth spoke to Network members of her ground-breaking
work. We have written to Elizabeth's family to express the Network's condolences.
Wanted To Buy
Dick Ronan (Tamworth)
wishes to buy a 3-wheel rear-wheel-drive wheelchair with a chain-driven hand
crank. If you have such a wheelchair and are willing to part with it, Dick
would love to hear from you on (02) 6765 6858.
Dr Henry writes ...
Henry Holland MD, is a polio survivor, a board certified psychiatrist and
an associate clinical professor of psychiatry at the Medical College of Virginia
who has led the Central Virginia (Richmond) PPS (Post-Polio Syndrome) Support
Group for the past two years.
He had a serious case of polio at age 11 in
1950 and accepted a permanent tracheostomy in 1970. His PPS symptoms started
in 1990, and he was recently forced by them to give up his practice.
Dr Holland writes "I have learned a lot
from reading the postings to the (Internet) Post-Polio Mailing Lists. I have
noticed considerable questioning about medical matters in regard to PPS, various
pros and cons of medications, and a variety of alternative and non-traditional
treatments for PPS which may help some but not others. As a physician, I have
observed a fair amount of doctor bashing, much of which may be justified.
I have decided to begin posting to possibly be of some help to other PPSers
and hopefully to provide some medical balance."
A series of Dr Holland's posts appears on
the Internet on the Lincolnshire Post-Polio Network's Web site www.zynet.co.uk/ott/polio/lincolnshire/
under the title "Dr Henry Writes ..." Dr Holland has generously
given us permission to reproduce his articles in the Newsletter and the first
one I have chosen addresses a topic we are all familiar with. Dr Holland's
permission must be sought to reprint any articles published in this series.
Massive Denial
Henry Holland MD
Richmond, Virginia, USA
23 April 1998
Denial is a word that is frequently overused in American
life. We hear it used as it pertains to the method in which many substance
abusers or their co-dependent spouses cope. Elizabeth Kubler Ross identified
denial as one of the early stages in the process of dying from a terminal
illness such as cancer. In the book of Matthew in the New Testament, even
Jesus advocates self-denial as a virtue when he says, "If any man will
come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me."
The dictionary offers several definitions for denial such as rejection of
a request, refusal to admit the truth of a statement or charge, disavowal,
and restrictions on one's own activity or desires. Perhaps all of us, at one
time or another, have exercised denial in these four ways. In the psychodynamic
world, denial is recognised as a defence mechanism. What is a defence mechanism?
A defence mechanism is defined as an unconscious intrapsychic process serving
to provide relief from emotional conflict and anxiety. Conscious efforts are
often made for similar reasons, but most defence mechanisms are unconscious,
meaning that their use is not a rational, wilful cognitive function of our
personalities. Denial is one of at least 17 recognised unconscious defence
mechanisms of our personalities. As a defence mechanism, denial is defined
as an unconscious process used to resolve emotional conflict and allay anxiety
by disavowing thoughts, feelings, wishes, needs, or external reality factors
that are consciously intolerable.
Polio survivors have exercised denial to a massive extent
for years and have demonstrated how successful this defence can be. Everyone
is different in personality, but massive denial has been remarkably incorporated
into the lifestyle of countless polio survivors. For those who survived polio
with some identifiable residual damage from the disease or displayed an outward
sign such as a brace, a limp, atrophy of an extremity, spinal curvature, brace,
crutches, or wheelchair, this reality set them apart from their able bodied
peers. For anyone, but particularly a child, this awareness, self-consciousness,
or feeling was unacceptable in order to feel normal. To consciously feel abnormal,
crippled, or deformed was very anxiety provoking. The thought or feeling of
being different from one's peers in the classroom, at play, or within the
family was unbearable and frightening. To regain some sense of selfhood and
a healthier identity, many polio survivors began a process of unconscious
denial. At the same time, many were also regaining some use of previously
paralysed muscles. With the encouragement of family, friends, doctors, nurses,
physical therapists and many others, measurable improvement occurred and the
denial process became even easier to adopt.
How often did crippled polio children secretly entertain
"what if" wishes or fantasies? I would estimate that the majority
did at least for several months if not years after the polio event. To be
surrounded by peers who took walking and running for granted, one would naturally
wonder "what if I had never had polio?" In time as this wishful
thinking would only produce anger and anxiety, one would gradually adapt to
the denial defence and in time, the frequency of such unrealistic wishes subsided.
"Why punish myself with such fantasies and wishes, it does not do me
any good, it only makes me feel worse."
Polio survivors clearly had many identifiable needs
unless they completely recovered or were able to pass for normal. Some were
severely damaged and needed wheelchairs or even iron lungs. Others needed
braces, corsets, crutches, or canes. Many others underwent painful orthopaedic
surgery and rehabilitation. The overwhelming goal for polio survivors of the
20s to the 50s was to find some way to get back on one's feet. The world would
be greatly limited or nearly inaccessible to those who could not get back
on their feet. Needs were hard to deny, especially if a crippled polio fell
and could not get back on his/her feet without assistance from another individual.
Falling was frightening to so many, not so much because of possible injury,
but more so from the fear of being an object of pity and "needing"
help to simply get up. How many polios, whether walking with braces or even
rolling in wheelchairs, were stubbornly aggressive about opening their own
doors or carrying their own objects? Most of us, not only denied, but also
resented our obvious need for the assistance that would have made our lives
simpler. Many of us became automatic in our refusal to accept the help of
others rather than graciously accept the good intentions of others. To admit
to ourselves that we had needs was intolerable. We were extremely vulnerable
to become absorbed into a life of massive denial. We did just that, became
masters of massive denial.
Our massive denial has resulted in a scattered group
of variously handicapped individuals who have achieved, contributed to the
work force, married, raised families, have done everything humanly possible
to be normal, and have successfully denied our polio realities, thoughts,
feelings, wishes, and needs. We were fully expecting to complete our life's
course with our denial defence intact and die of natural causes like our normal
peers. Polio was past history, and then came the unexpected.
A little over a decade ago, post-polio syndrome (PPS)
became a new reality. Our well-oiled denial defence initially seemed to be
helpful with PPS. We could simply convince ourselves that this was something
that was only happening to a few polios and it would not happen to me. Or,
even if it did happen, it was just a matter of "pushing through"
the pain, fatigue, and weakness. The "no pain, no gain" strategy
had worked so well in the past, why wouldn't it work now? Our massive denial
was still operant. We all know what happened next. PPS began happening to
me, as well as you, and finally to the majority of us. Some of us went to
many doctors before getting a proper diagnosis. Some of us went to a support
group meeting and did not like what we saw or heard and did not go back with
eagerness. To go to a support group meeting was a direct insult to our denial
armour. One might see a mirror image of oneself across the room. What would
we likely see? We would likely see a person with needs and realities that
we did not want to accept in ourselves. Again, our denial armour might be
chipped or cracked.
The whole experience of PPS is like a boomerang or a
déjà vu experience. We have been caught off guard and our massive
denial defence has been invaded and penetrated. What has been the result?
Many of us have experienced overt anxiety, depression, anger, physical and
emotional pain, loss of jobs and self esteem, family stress, and eventual
resignation to an unfair fate. For those who had been "passers",
the whole PPS experience has been an old nightmare or a regression back to
an experience they had assumed they had beaten. Massive denial had not been
necessary for most passers, but they too were unprepared for PPS and its realities.
Massive denial, was it good for us or not? Do we still
need it? Will our minds find an unconscious replacement? These are questions
to ponder. I doubt that we will relinquish massive denial. It has been so
good to us. Even with PPS, if we have a good day, do we not entertain thoughts
and feelings that we can overcome again? Do we not search for more knowledge
about PPS, try many untested remedies, share information with each other,
and try to gain some semblance of autonomy, even when it is compromised by
undeniable realities. Becoming a burden is the last thing we want to be. We
must have control of our existence. Denial of our control will likely be our
demise.
Only as a result of PPS have we discovered each other.
We have helped each other uncover and share our polio pasts, and now we should
be better able to support each other, as we grow old in our polio futures.
With the knowledge of having and knowing each other, may massive denial go
on a much needed and long recess?
Abnormal Movements in Sleep as a Post-Polio Sequelae
Richard L Bruno, PhD
The Post-Polio Institute
Englewood Hospital and Medical Center, Englewood, New Jersey USA
This paper was published in the American Journal of Physical Medicine and
Rehabilitation, 1998; 77: 1-6, and is reprinted here with permission of
the author. The paper is quite technical in parts but is certainly worth reading
by you and/or your doctor.
Abstract
Nearly two-thirds of polio survivors report abnormal
movements in sleep (AMS), with 52% reporting that their sleep is disturbed
by AMS. Sleep studies were performed in seven polio survivors to objectively
document AMS. Two patients demonstrated Generalised Random Myoclonus (GRM),
brief contractions and even ballistic movements of the arms and legs, slow
repeated grasping movements of the hands, slow flexion of the arms and contraction
of the shoulder and pectoral muscles. Two other patients demonstrated Periodic
Movements in Sleep (PMS) with muscle contractions and ballistic movements
of the legs, two had PMS plus Restless Leg Syndrome (RLS) and one had sleep
starts involving only contraction of the arm muscles. AMS occurred in Stage
II sleep in all patients, in Stage I in some, and could significantly disturb
sleep architecture even though patients were totally unaware of muscle contractions.
Poliovirus-induced damage to the spinal cord and brain is presented as a possible
cause of AMS. The diagnosis of post-polio fatigue, evaluation of AMS, and
management of AMS using benzodiazepines or dopamimetic agents is described.
Despite numerous late-onset symptoms reported by polio survivors - fatigue,
muscle weakness, pain, cold intolerance, swallowing and breathing difficulties
- one symptom was totally unexpected: abnormal movements in sleep (AMS). As
early as 1984 our post-polio patients were reporting muscle contractions as
they fell asleep. The 1985 National Post Polio Survey included two questions
about AMS: "Do your muscles twitch or jump as you fall asleep" and
"Is your sleep disturbed by muscle twitching?" [1]. It was surprising
that 63% of the 676 respondents reported that their muscles did twitch and
jump during sleep and that 52% - a third of the entire sample - said that
their sleep was disturbed by twitching.
These percentages are markedly elevated as compared
to the incidence of AMS in the general population. In one survey only 29%
of those without neurological disease who were at least 50 years old reported
AMS, versus 63% of surveyed polio survivors who were 52 years old on average
[2]. In another survey only 34% of those older than 64 reported AMS, slightly
more than half the incidence of AMS in the younger post-polio sample [3] Given
the apparent increased prevalence of AMS in polio survivors, and with daytime
fatigue the most commonly reported Post-Polio Sequelae (PPS), we were interested
in objectively documenting AMS, relating them to possible disturbances in
sleep architecture and identifying an effective treatment for AMS [1].
Methods
Subjects.
Seven polio survivors were referred for sleep studies to a sleep disorders
center. This was a sample of convenience, in that the subjects were patients
presenting with PPS who themselves knew (three patients) or whose bed mates
knew (four patients) that AMS were occurring. Patients were on average 54
years old and 44 years post acute polio which occurred at age 10. The patients
had had AMS for a mean of eight years which was on average 35 years post acute
polio. Patients reported moderate-to-severe difficulty sleeping at night and
moderate-to-severe daytime fatigue that did not respond to the treatments
of choice for post-polio fatigue, that is, pacing of activities, daytime rest
periods, energy conservation and use of appropriate assistive devices [4].
In addition to fatigue, patients reported an average of two limbs having late-onset
muscle weakness.
Procedure.
Patients underwent a standard polysomnographic evaluation with EEG and facial
EMG recorded for sleep staging [5]. Blood oxygen saturation, measured using
a finger pulse oxymeter, chest and abdominal wall excursion and nasal air
temperature were also recorded; video monitoring of sleep was also performed.
Surface EMG was recorded from patients' legs as well as from limbs in which
AMS were reported.
Results
Four types of AMS were seen. Two patients presented
with what has been called Generalised Random Myoclonus (GRM) [1] [6], two
patients had Periodic Movements in Sleep (PMS), two had PMS plus Restless
Leg Syndrome (RLS) and one had Sleep Starts (also called "hypnogogic
massive myoclonic jerks").
Generalised Random Myoclonus. GRM was seen in two patients.
One had had bulbar polio with little or no arm or leg involvement acutely,
while the other has been diplegic since polio but had no bulbar or respiratory
symptoms acutely. These patients had random contractions of muscles throughout
their bodies. One had such violent contractions of the trunk muscles that
she was pulled into the foetal position during the night. This patient had
been very aware of GRM for about 10 years.
However, the other patient had been completely unaware
of GRM until they were noticed by her husband. Random, rapid muscle contractions
were noted in all four limbs, jaw and pectoral muscles, in addition to slow
repeated grasping movements of the hands, slow flexion of the arms and movement
of the shoulders. The presence of bilateral toe flexion was notable since
the patient's right leg has always been totally paralysed except for a minimal
ability to flex her toes; the toes of her right foot contracted numerous times
during the night.
In both patients, GRM occurred during Stage II sleep;
the latter patient also had GRM in Stage I. The patient with violent trunk
flexion had muscle contractions, causing a severe disturbance of sleep architecture,
only during the first third of the night. She also had a few episodes of obstructive
apnoea that were not related to the muscle contractions but did disturb her
sleep. She was prescribed clonazepam, 0.5 mg B.I.D., which eliminated her
GRM. The other patient had GRM throughout the night but had no disturbance
of sleep architecture and was not treated pharmacologically.
Periodic Movements in Sleep. Two patients demonstrated PMS with
contractions only of the leg muscles of which neither patient was aware. Both
had limb and respiratory involvement with the acute polio and had PMS during
Stage II sleep with one patient also having muscle contractions during Stage
I. The former patient had nearly continuous EMG activity in his legs throughout
the night and had a severe disturbance of sleep architecture. He also had
some central episodes of apnoea early in the night as he was falling asleep
that did not disturb his sleep. The latter patient had PMS occurring only
during the first half of the night which caused no disturbance of sleep architecture.
However, he had frequent hypopnoeas which did severely disturb his sleep.
Both patients were prescribed lorazepam, 1.0 mg H.S., which eliminated the
PMS.
PMS plus Restless Leg Syndrome. Two patients had PMS plus Restless
Legs Syndrome. RLS is characterised by the subjective feeling that the legs
must be moved. This feeling increases during the evening, often preventing
sleep onset because patients feel as if they must get up and walk. The patients
with PMS plus RLS had been very little affected by the acute polio, one having
no polio residual and the other having one leg weakened. PMS were seen in
both legs and occurred during Stage II in both patients and during Stage I
in one patient. One patient's leg muscle contractions were so violent that
she was propelled one to two inches off the surface of the bed. Although her
PMS occurred only during the first half of the night, her sleep was severely
disturbed and she was very aware that she had had PMS for about 5 years. She
was prescribed L-dopa/carbidopa (Sinemet) 200/50 mg, 1/2 tablet B.I.D., and
clonazepam, 0.5 mg H.S. and at 3 A.M., which reduced the RLS and PMS by about
80% and allowed her to have a restful night's sleep.
The other patient did not know he had PMS which were
continuous throughout the night and did moderately disturb his sleep architecture.
He was prescribed L-dopa/carbidopa, 200/50 mg H.S., which eliminated his RLS
and PMS.
Sleep Start. One patient was diagnosed as having a Sleep Start,
her arms ballistically abducting as she began to fall asleep. She was very
mildly affected by the acute polio and had no AMS in the legs, even in the
leg in which she reported new muscle weakness. The patient's sleep was markedly
disturbed since her arms would move as she started to fall asleep and prevent
sleep onset. She was prescribed alprazolam, 0.125 mg H.S., which eliminated
her AMS.
Discussion
Sleep studies in this sampling of post-polio patients
objectively documented three different types of AMS. Whether other types or
combinations of AMS occur in polio survivors cannot be determined from this
study, nor can this study or the 1985 National Post-Polio Survey state the
actual incidence of AMS in polio survivors, since neither sample was random
or population-based. However, the objective documentation of AMS in these
post-polio patients, and the Post-Polio Survey finding that 63% of polio survivors
reported muscle "twitching or jumping" as they fell asleep, suggest
that AMS may in some way be related to the pathophysiology of the original
poliovirus infection.
In 1964, Loeb coined the phrase "hypnic myoclonus"
to describe muscle contractions during sleep onset in healthy individuals
without neurological disease [7] Loeb described the contractions as rapid
(less than 0.5 seconds long), arrhythmic (occurring without a pattern) and
causing a variety of movements - finger flexion, thumb adduction, forearm
and foot flexion and extension, shoulder elevation and facial twitching during
Stages I and II sleep - identical to those seen in the post-polio patients.
However, in contrast to the post-polio patients, none of Loeb's subjects demonstrated
contractions in more than one muscle group and in none was sleep disturbed
by hypnic myoclonus.
Loeb thought that hypnic myoclonus resulted from an
abnormality at the level of the brain stem reticular formation causing decreased
descending inhibition of anterior horn motor neurons during sleep. Martinelli
[8] thought PMS also resulted from an increase in anterior horn cell excitability,
with Walters [9] finding that PMS decreased with the administration of an
opiate receptor agonist.
Loeb and Askenasy suggested that AMS were also related
to abnormal discharges from the thalamus, cerebellum and basal ganglia [7]
[10]. The implication of the basal ganglia in the generation of AMS is interesting
since PMS are common in patients with Parkinson's disease, whose decreased
dopamine production impairs basal ganglia functioning, in patients with narcolepsy,
who have an increased number and sensitivity of dopamine receptors in the
basal ganglia, and have been found to decrease with the administration of
dopamine receptor agonists [9] [11] [12].
AMS, Polioencephalitis and Poliomyelitis. All of the CNS regions
implicated in the pathogenesis of AMS are known to have been lesioned by the
poliovirus. The anterior horn motor neurons, cerebellar nuclei and reticular
formation were frequently and severely damaged by the poliovirus [13]. The
periaquiductal gray, paraventricular hypothalamus and lamina II dorsal horn
neurons were all lesioned by the poliovirus (cf. [9] [13]); damage to these
opioid peptide-secreting neurons may be evidenced not only by AMS but also
by polio survivors' doubled sensitivity to pain [14] [15] [16]. Finally, the
thalamus and basal ganglia (the substantia nigra, putamen and globus pallidus)
were also damaged by the poliovirus, damage that has been implicated in the
pathogenesis of post-polio fatigue [16] [17] [18]. Given the distribution
and extent of poliovirus lesions in all of the CNS areas implicated in the
pathogenesis of AMS, we should not have been surprised in 1985 that a majority
of polio survivors reported muscles that twitch and jump during sleep.
Clinical Implications. PPS remains a diagnosis of exclusion.
All possible causes for new symptoms in polio survivors, especially causes
for late-onset fatigue, must be ruled out before the diagnosis of PPS is made.
Therefore, it is important to rule out a sleep disorder as a cause of late-onset
fatigue. Clinicians need to take a thorough sleep history from their post-polio
patients, asking not only about symptoms of sleep apnoea, which occurs frequently
in polio survivors, but also about AMS [20]. The patient's bed partner must
also be asked about AMS since the majority of polio survivors will not know
that they have AMS.
Patients are referred for a sleep study if sleep apnoea
or AMS is suspected. The lowest dose of a short acting benzodiazepine will
be prescribed before sleep by the Post-Polio Institute physiatrist if a patient
has AMS, since these medications seem to virtually eliminate GRM and PMS in
our post-polio patients. Treatment of sleep apnoea is deferred to the sleep
disorders center as is treatment for RLS, since a dopamimetic agent in combination
with a benzodiazepine may be required. However, there is a caveat to prescribing
dopamimetics for polio survivors. One of our PPS patients developed vasovagal
syncope with cardiac asystole during the administration of a dopamine receptor
agonist [21]. We consider a history of vasovagal syncope or unexplained faints
a contraindication to prescribing dopamimetics for polio survivors with AMS
or RLS [22].
References
- Bruno RL, Frick NM: Stress and "Type A" behavior as precipitants
of Post-Polio Sequelae: The Felician/Columbia Survey, in Halstead
LS, Wiechers DO (eds): Research and Clinical Aspects of the Late Effects
of Poliomyelitis. White Plains, NY, March of Dimes Research Foundation,
1987, pp 145-155.
- Lugaresi E, Cirinotta F, Zucconi M, et al.: Good and poor sleepers:
An epidemiological survey, in Guilleminault C, Lugaresi E (eds): Sleep/wake
disorders: Natural history, epidemiology, and long-term evolution.
NY, Raven, 1983, pp 265-295.
- Ancoli-Israel S, Kripke DF, Mason W, Kaplan OJ: Sleep apnea and
periodic movements in an aging sample. J Gerontol 1985; 40 419-425.
- Creange SJ, Bruno RL: Compliance with treatment for Post-Polio Sequelae:
Effect of Type A behavior, self- concept and loneliness. Am J PM&R
1997; 76:378-382.
- Rectschaffen A, Kales A: A manual of standardized terminology, techniques
and scoring system for sleep stages of human subjects, Los Angeles,
UCLA Brain Information Service/Brain Research Institute, 1968.
- Bruno RL, Frick NM, Creange SJ: Nocturnal generalized myoclonus
as a post-polio sequelae. Arch PM&R 1995; 76:594.
- Loeb C: Etude polygraphique des Myoclonies hypniques chez l'homme.
Rev Neurol 1964;110:258-268.
- Martinelli P, Coccagna G, Lugaresi E: Nocturnal myoclonus, restless
legs syndrome and abnormal electrophysiological findings. Ann Neurol
1987;21:515.
- Walters A, Henning W, Cote L, et al.: Dominantly inherited restless
legs with myoclonus and periodic movements in sleep: A syndrome related
to endogenous? Adv Neurol 1986; 43:309-319.
- Askenasy JJM, Weitzman ED, Yahr MD: Are periodic movements in sleep
a basal ganglia dysfunction? J Neural Transm 1987;70:337-347.
- Weiner WJ, Lang AE: Myoclonus and related syndromes, in Weiner WJ,
Lang AE: (eds): Movement Disorders. Mount Kisco, Futura, 1989, pp 457-529.
- Boivin DB, Lorrain D, Montplasir J: Effects of bromocriptine on
periodic limb movements in human narcolepsy. Neurol 1993; 43:2134-2136.
- Bodian D: Histopathological basic of clinical findings in poliomyelitis.
Am J Med 1949;6:563-578.
- Bruno RL, Johnson JC, Berman WS: Motor and sensory functioning with
changing ambient temperature in post-polio subjects, in Halstead LS,
Wiechers DO (eds): Late Effects of Poliomyelitis. Miami, Symposia
Foundation, 1985.
- Bruno RL, Johnson JC, Berman WS: Vasomotor abnormalities as Post-Polio
Sequelae. Orthopedics 1985;8: 865-869.
- Bruno RL, Frick NM, Cohen, J: Polioencephalitis, stress and the
etiology of Post-Polio Sequelae. Orthopedics 1991; 14:1269-1276.
- Bruno RL, Sapolsky R, Zimmerman JR, Frick NM: The pathophysiology
of a central cause of post-polio fatigue. Ann NY Acad Sci 1995;753:257-275.
- Bruno RL, Frick NM, Creange SJ, et al.: Polioencephalitis and the
brain fatigue generator model of post-viral fatigue syndromes. J Chronic
Fatigue Syndrome 1996;2:5-27.
- Bruno RL, Creange SJ, Zimmerman JR, Frick NM: Elevated plasma prolactin
and EEG slow wave power in post-polio fatigue: Implications for a dopamine
deficiency underlying chronic fatigue syndromes. J Chronic Fatigue
Syndrome, 1998 (in press).
- Bach JR, Alba AS: Pulmonary dysfunction and sleep disordered breathing
as post-polio sequelae: Evaluation and management. Orthopedics 1991;14:1329-1337
- Bruno RL, Zimmerman JR, Creange SJ, et al.: Bromocriptine in the
treatment of post-polio fatigue: A pilot study with implications for the
pathophysiology of fatigue. Am J PM&R 1996; 75:340-347.
- Bruno RL: Chronic fatigue, fainting and autonomic dysfunction: Further
similarities between Post-Polio Fatigue and Chronic Fatigue Syndrome?
J Chronic Fatigue Syndrome 1997; 3:107-117.
Support Group Report
Bernie O'Grady Phone:
(02) 9688 3135
Support Group Co-ordinator
I am grateful to Joan Mobey whose previous writings
for the Network on Support Groups provide the basis for this article.
Why Do We Need Support Groups?
All people are influenced by the experiences of their
lives and polio people, profoundly so. Many of us had extreme trauma at an
early age and were separated from loved ones when we needed them most. After
discharge from hospital we were told to get on with our lives as if nothing
had happened. We all struggled through life with our disability but were not
to tell how hard it was and so we buttoned up our lips and became determined
to prove that we were just as good, if not better, than anyone else. A lot
of us have gone through life with great difficulty and don't even want to
talk about it; we have withdrawn into our shell which is a world of silence
about what is polio.
Now later in life many of us can no longer hide our
pain and disability but we still refuse to talk about it.
A Support Group gives us a chance to meet other people
who have similar problems and who also have suffered in silence, and so finally
you can meet and talk to others who can help you to start talking about your
past and present life, and to pool and share information which will give you
the opportunity to now review your life and notice that you are not the same
as the average able-bodied person. We can help each other to live our lives
in a more realistic way and then perhaps we can let up on the pace of our
past life and set goals more realistically.
If this picture of self denial of having had polio,
of not wanting to talk about new problems, of the loss of friends because
you are unable to perform as good as they, of not accepting any help or advice
fits you, then it may be time you broke down the barrier, admit that you have
a problem, and accept the fact that there is help out there - a Support Group.
When you first join in a Group of course you will have
fears, will I be accepted, will they listen to how I feel about my past and
present. What will happen if my emotions get the better of me and I break
down and cry. Of course people won't think any worse of you, because you are
among friends. This is what a Support Group is about. You will be talking
to people who have the same physical and emotional problems as yourself.
Adjusting to change is made easier as people are nourished
by the sense of togetherness that is available nowhere else. Some come to
the Group, receive what they need, and leave to carry on life, never to return.
Others leave and return only when symptoms flare. Still others who cherish
the on-going relationship with Group members continue to attend even after
their initial needs have been met. As some members depart, the Group is replenished
by newcomers. They are beginning their search for understanding and acceptance
of new losses knowing what those who have come before them have known: some
things are done more easily in a group of people with similar experiences
than done alone. The cycle continues.
The Convener will make you feel welcome and introduce
you to the other members who will be only too willing to listen to your story
and to share theirs and so through tears, laughter and trembling this burden
that you have been carrying will be greatly eased because you will be among
friends, then you will say to yourself, why didn't I join a long time ago?
Support Group Update
Cowra Support Group Convener
: Vera White
Vera is looking for members to join her Support Group.
Vera is happy to set up the Group for people who would like to regularly come
together on a face-to-face basis at a designated place. She will also set
up a Telephone Support Group for those who find travelling difficult, and
Vera will visit any member who is house bound providing the distance is not
too far.
Vera is very interested in setting up a letter-writing
"Round Robin" for isolated polio people to keep in touch with each
other. Members write their own story in an exercise book, pass it on to the
next member, they in turn read your story and write their own, and so on until
it returns to the Convener to be sent on its way again.
Members, we have a Convener who is happy to help you
in all these ways and so there is no excuse not to consider joining this local
Support Group. Vera is waiting for your call now on (02) 6342 2647.
Albury Support Group Convener
: Neil von Schill
Since the inception of the Support Group network the
Albury Group has operated as a Telephone Group. Mid 1998 the Group met in
person for the first time and now plan to meet three or four times per year.
Because of their position on the border, some of the Group are members of
both the New South Wales and Victorian Post-Polio Networks. They have met
to investigate how they can cater for the needs of members on both sides of
the Murray River, and will continue to work to provide available benefits
to them. For example, there are services available to Victorian members which
Neil has been able to access. Neil would like to hear from members in his
area who would like to join his Support Group. Please telephone him on (02)
6025 6169.
Northern Inland Support Group Convener
: Barbara Chapman-Woods
On Sunday 18 October, Barbara convened a meeting at
the St Andrews Village Hall, Tamworth, which I attended. Polio members and
friends travelled from Sydney, Newcastle, Armidale, Coffs Harbour, as well
as from Tamworth and its outlying areas. The day commenced at 11 am with Barbara
welcoming and introducing members and reading letters of apology from those
members not able to come on the day.
Barbara (telephone (02) 6766 5093) successfully operates
a "Round Robin" for her members because of the isolation and distances
between towns, and shared with us many of the stories written by members of
her Group. Following this, Barbara invited six members to tell their story
from the time they contracted polio, and of their personal coping experiences
through life with their disability. Each person expressed many setbacks and
hardship, but conveyed a message of determination and struggle to prove they
were as good as the next person. They were all very positive and cheerful.
The day concluded at 1 pm. Lunch was provided, prepared
by Barbara's friends at the Village. Thank you - we enjoyed the opportunity
to meet and get to know new friends.
Wollongong Support Group Convener
: Dorothy Robinson
This Support Group had their first face-to-face meeting
on Friday 20 November 1998, at Port Kembla Hospital at 3 pm, and Dorothy reports
it was very successful. Their next meeting will be held on Friday 12 February
1999 in the Conference Room, West Wing, Port Kembla Hospital from 2 - 4 pm.
Any member wishing to join this Support Group, please telephone Dorothy Robinson
on (02) 4229 6221.
Conveners Needed
We still need Conveners for: Eastern
Suburbs
If you can help, we'd love to hear from you.
This is my final Support Group Report for this year. 1998 has been a fruitful
and successful year for the Network and its Support Groups. Ten new Support
Groups were started, some have been revitalised and other Groups continue
to be strong.
I thank all Conveners and Go-Conveners for the support
you provide to our members, and wish you all the best for the festive season.
For Sale
Mary Le Clair (Neutral
Bay) has decided to get a smaller scooter better suited to her house and wishes
to sell her current machine. It is a Shoprider 4-wheel model which
Mary tells us is two and a half years old and in excellent condition. Mary
is asking $2,200 or near offer (she advises a new model costs $4,700)
and can be contacted on (02) 9953 5415.
Dick Ronan (Tamworth)
also wishes to sell his Shoprider 4-wheel electric scooter which comes
complete with basket and light. Dick tells us that the scooter is two years
old, however its batteries and tyres are only six months old. Dick is asking
$2,500 and can be contacted on (02) 6765 6858.
Post-Polio Seminar Program : 1999
The Program for the 1999 Post-Polio Seminars has been
decided and the dates set. The Program is varied and should appeal to all.
Please note the dates in your diaries so you don't miss out on some wonderful
speakers. Final confirmation of dates, speakers and venues, and further details
of each Seminar topic, will be given in the Newsletter issued prior
to the Seminar.
| Saturday, 6 March 1999 |
Seminar : |
Orthotics and You |
| |
Presenter : |
Michael Gurry B.Pros.&Orth., MAOPA |
| |
Venue : |
The Northcott Society, Parramatta |
| Saturday, 10 July 1999 |
Seminar : |
2000 Paralympics / Customised Clothing |
| |
Presenter : |
Speakers to be advised |
| |
Venue : |
St Paul's Anglican Church Hall, Kogarah |
| Saturday, 21 August 1999 |
Seminar : |
(program being developed) |
| |
Presenter : |
|
| |
Venue : |
|
| Sunday, 22 August 1999 |
Seminar : |
Support Group Conveners' Workshop |
| |
Presenter : |
|
| |
Venue : |
Venue : Coffs Harbour (actual venue to be advised) |
| Sunday, 30 October 1999 |
Seminar : |
Food For Thought |
| |
Presenter : |
Dietitian - speaker to be advised |
| |
Venue : |
Independent Living Centre, Ryde |
- POST-POLIO POST .
+ .
+ .
+
Following the Conference "Managing the Late Effects of Polio"
held by the Network in Canberra in August, member Kerry Jenkin wrote to express
her delight at her attendance.
As a newcomer to the Post-Polio Network and a recently-commissioned
Convener for the Hornsby area, I would like to take this opportunity of extending
my personal thanks to Gillian our President, Bernie the Co-ordinator of the
Support Group Conveners, and the entire ACT Support Group for presenting a
wonderful Conference. I felt very elated by the enthusiasm of the participants
and was astonished at the number of people including the speakers who had
suffered from the virus and still went on to make the service of fellow sufferers
their career. All speakers had first-hand knowledge but showed extraordinary
enthusiasm in sharing their experiences with those present.
One thing I have found since contacting PPN and listening
to other people is that my awareness is quite lacking and that certain demons
I thought were buried many years ago have resurfaced leaving a bad taste in
my mouth. I contracted polio during the war and my mother was told "you
may as well let her die". As a child who suffered total paralysis, my
mother had to leave two other children at home without a father in order that
I be fed in Camperdown, as it wasn't the duty of the staff.
There was no suggestion of a clinic run by Sister Kenny
or the Northcott Society - perhaps it was too early - but we went to the Mosman
Spastic Centre newly opened where instead of fees the parents could do manual
work to pay for the use of facilities and education.
I have had a wonderful career of thirty-four years and
I think that my time since retirement has been the best. It is a time of no
longer having to apologise or ask permission. If I'm tired or if my body is
not behaving as well as usual, I can stay in bed, go for a stroll, or do nothing,
it's okay.
As Convener of the Hornsby Support Group I hope to see
as many members as possible from the area, as soon as possible. Not to be
forgotten, thank you to all those husbands, wives and family supporting your
PPS loved one.
Roger Smith has asked me to pass on his thanks to everyone who gave him
advice and information in regard to strong lightweight calipers. Roger says
he will be following up your suggestions soon.
The Management
Committee wishes you a
Happy and Holy Christmas
and a
Healthy and Peaceful New Year
Return to Main Newsletter Page